Waiver Wire WeeklyNathan Staub Memorial Newsletter archive

The trade desk

Who won the trade?

Started points tell one story. Future picks get to keep their lawyer.

Winners are based on realized started points while received assets stayed with the receiving manager. Multi-team deals compare every side. Unresolved picks prevent a final verdict. Dynasty market-value changes are unavailable from the free public Sleeper API and are not invented. How trades are scored.

2025 · Week/bucket 4

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

Killen Kehillah

45.90

Realized started points · net edge 45.90

  • Zach Charbonnet: 45.90 started, 157.30 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Abominable Snowmen

0.00

Realized started points · net edge -45.90

  • 2026 round 2 (original roster 4): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: Killen Kehillah

2025 · Week/bucket 4

The Dirtiest wins on realized started points so far

2 teams

The Dirtiest

89.10

Realized started points · net edge 22.70

  • Emeka Egbuka: 89.10 started, 124.60 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

MauiHowie

66.40

Realized started points · net edge -22.70

  • Jordan Mason: 66.40 started, 80.80 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: The Dirtiest

2025 · Week/bucket 3

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

The Dirtiest

0.00

Realized started points · net edge -237.70

  • Jameson Williams: 0.00 started, 0.00 roster points
  • 2026 round 3 (original roster 4): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Killen Kehillah

237.70

Realized started points · net edge 237.70

  • Travis Etienne: 237.70 started, 237.70 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: Killen Kehillah

2025 · Week/bucket 1

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

Cam Newtons fantasty

408.70

Realized started points · net edge 383.00

  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 1) → Tetairoa McMillan: 250.10 started, 285.90 roster points
  • 2025 round 2 (original roster 9) → Tyler Warren: 158.60 started, 227.90 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

The Dirtiest

25.70

Realized started points · net edge -383.00

  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 6) → Ashton Jeanty: 25.70 started, 25.70 roster points
  • 2026 round 2 (original roster 1): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: Cam Newtons fantasty

2025 · Week/bucket 1

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

Cam Newtons fantasty

0.00

Realized started points · net edge -114.50

  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 6): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Newmen

114.50

Realized started points · net edge 114.50

  • Terry McLaurin: 34.60 started, 34.60 roster points
  • Jonathan Taylor: 62.30 started, 62.30 roster points
  • 2025 round 3 (original roster 1) → Devin Neal: 0.00 started, 0.00 roster points
  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 5) → Travis Hunter: 17.60 started, 67.80 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: Newmen

2025 · Week/bucket 1

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

The Dirtiest

306.30

Realized started points · net edge 159.00

  • De'Von Achane: 306.30 started, 306.30 roster points
  • 2025 round 2 (original roster 9): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

SuckMyPresticles

147.30

Realized started points · net edge -159.00

  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 4) → Quinshon Judkins: 147.30 started, 226.10 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: The Dirtiest

2025 · Week/bucket 1

Afghan National Team wins on realized started points so far

2 teams

Afghan National Team

5.00

Realized started points · net edge 5.00

  • Calvin Ridley: 5.00 started, 17.40 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

SuckMyPresticles

0.00

Realized started points · net edge -5.00

  • Tank Bigsby: 0.00 started, 0.00 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: Afghan National Team

2025 · Week/bucket 1

MauiHowie wins on realized started points so far

2 teams

The Dirtiest

0.00

Realized started points · net edge -281.60

  • Rashee Rice: 0.00 started, 0.00 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

MauiHowie

281.60

Realized started points · net edge 281.60

  • D'Andre Swift: 253.60 started, 299.90 roster points
  • 2025 round 2 (original roster 5) → Cam Ward: 0.00 started, 47.64 roster points
  • 2025 round 3 (original roster 5) → Kyle Pitts: 28.00 started, 237.70 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: MauiHowie

2025 · Week/bucket 1

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

The Dirtiest

0.00

Realized started points · net edge 0.00

  • 2025 round 2 (original roster 1) → Jayden Higgins: 0.00 started, 57.10 roster points
  • 2025 round 3 (original roster 5): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Abominable Snowmen

0.00

Realized started points · net edge 0.00

  • Jonnu Smith: 0.00 started, 14.60 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: The Dirtiest

2025 · Week/bucket 1

MauiHowie wins on realized started points so far

2 teams

Afghan National Team

12.00

Realized started points · net edge -79.50

  • Cooper Kupp: 12.00 started, 113.80 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

MauiHowie

91.50

Realized started points · net edge 79.50

  • Jaylen Waddle: 40.50 started, 40.50 roster points
  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 3) → Emeka Egbuka: 51.00 started, 51.00 roster points
  • 2025 round 2 (original roster 3) → Kaleb Johnson: 0.00 started, 7.70 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: MauiHowie

2025 · Week/bucket 1

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

Cam Newtons fantasty

17.80

Realized started points · net edge -441.56

  • Mark Andrews: 17.80 started, 129.50 roster points
  • Tank Dell: 0.00 started, 0.00 roster points
  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 5): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Abominable Snowmen

459.36

Realized started points · net edge 441.56

  • Jaxon Smith-Njigba: 459.36 started, 479.96 roster points
  • 2025 round 2 (original roster 1): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: Abominable Snowmen

2025 · Week/bucket 1

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

The Dirtiest

0.00

Realized started points · net edge -484.70

  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 4): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued
  • 2025 round 2 (original roster 5): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Abominable Snowmen

484.70

Realized started points · net edge 484.70

  • Christian McCaffrey: 484.70 started, 484.70 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: Abominable Snowmen

2024 · Week/bucket 13

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

The Dirtiest

33.20

Realized started points · net edge 33.20

  • Jonnu Smith: 33.20 started, 33.20 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

prestonbryant12

0.00

Realized started points · net edge -33.20

  • Taysom Hill: 0.00 started, 0.00 roster points
  • 2027 round 1 (original roster 2): pending. Future or uncached draft

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: The Dirtiest

2024 · Week/bucket 13

Pending picks; scoring leader only

2 teams

prestonbryant12

0.00

Realized started points · net edge -158.70

  • Zack Moss: 0.00 started, 0.00 roster points
  • 2025 round 2 (original roster 10) → Matthew Golden: 0.00 started, 65.60 roster points
  • 2026 round 1 (original roster 10): pending. Pick traded again; downstream trade tree is not valued

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

City Wok Rions

158.70

Realized started points · net edge 158.70

  • Michael Pittman: 158.70 started, 228.10 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: City Wok Rions

2024 · Week/bucket 13

Epstein’s Summer Camp wins on realized started points so far

2 teams

The Dirtiest

58.60

Realized started points · net edge -376.10

  • Tyreek Hill: 58.60 started, 87.20 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Epstein’s Summer Camp

434.70

Realized started points · net edge 376.10

  • Nico Collins: 288.80 started, 306.50 roster points
  • 2025 round 1 (original roster 2) → RJ Harvey: 145.90 started, 245.40 roster points

Net FAAB: 0. FAAB is listed separately and is not converted into fantasy points.

Original transaction and season history · Leader so far: Epstein’s Summer Camp